Recent Research on Boy Actors
Julian DeZotti as Margaret (left) and Derek Genova as Princess Elinor (right) in Friar Bacon.
In his article "How Old Were Shakespeare’s Boy Actors?"1, David Kathman examines evidence from all surviving cast lists and cross-referenced them with information from baptismal records and the records of the London livery companies to establish that: "until the early 1660s, female roles on the English stage (including the most demanding, complex parts) were played by adolescent boys, no younger than twelve and no older than twenty-one or twenty-two, with a median of around sixteen or seventeen.” 1
The actors playing female roles were referred to as boys in contemporary sources, but also as youths and young men (221). It would appear that the term boy was closely associated with apprenticeship. Once an individual had completed their apprenticeship they would be made a freeman of their livery company, which marked their transition into adulthood. At this point, usually around the age of twenty-four, a young man might consider marriage. A young man of twenty, therefore, may have biologically entered manhood but socially he remained a boy or at best a youth.
Kathman indirectly refers to young men in their twenties as "adolescent boys." This is an understandable inclination. First, he is trying to counter arguments made elsewhere that the more complex female roles would have been played by adult actors 2, and second because there is some evidence to suggest that puberty may have been delayed due to lower nutrition. But the latest age Kathman presents for the onset of puberty from contemporary sources is eighteen (222), and since we know women’s roles were played by actors older than eighteen it is reasonable to presume that female roles were played by post-pubescent young men. I am not arguing against Kathman here but merely clarifying a point. Indeed, Kathman presents evidence that apprentice actors in their late teens played the roles of young men and women in the same play.
There was therefore a degree of flexibility in the casting of the young apprentices in an Elizabethan company. One can imagine circumstances that would influence such casting. An actor that developed a basso-profundo voice and a grizzly beard at fifteen might progress more quickly to male roles; alternatively, an actor whose build remained slight, beard scanty and voice high, might continue to play female roles into his twenties.